Debunking the Myth: Does Bottled Water Cause Infertility?

The issue of infertility is complex, with numerous internal and external factors playing a role. Recently, there's been a growing concern regarding the potential impact of drinking water from polycarbonate (PC) or reusable plastic gallons on fertility. However, expert opinions assure us that this is a baseless myth.

No Evidence of a Link Between Bottled Water and Infertility

Dr. Abraham Dian Winarto, a prominent member of the Indonesian Obstetrics and Gynecology Association (POGI), categorically denies any connection between bottled water and infertility or any other health problems. He emphasizes the need for thorough research to establish any link between PC gallon water and infertility. "In my 15 years of practice, I haven't encountered any cases of infertility directly linked to bottled water," he stated in a written statement.

Dr. Winarto highlights the rigorous safety measures implemented by the Indonesian Food and Drug Administration (BPOM) for bottled water, especially branded products, ensuring their suitability for consumption.

The true culprits behind infertility fall into two distinct categories: internal and external factors.

Real Factors Affecting Fertility

Internal Factors

• Hormonal imbalances affecting ovulation in women and sperm production in men.
• Medical conditions such as endometriosis, polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), or reproductive tract infections that can negatively impact fertility.
• In men, conditions like varicocele or infections can also contribute to infertility.

External Factors

• Lifestyle choices, including smoking, excessive alcohol consumption, and illicit drug use.
• Extreme weight, both underweight and overweight.
• Severe or chronic stress that can disrupt hormonal balance and reproductive function.
• Age, as the quality and quantity of eggs in women and sperm in men decline with age.

Dr. Boyke Dian Nugraha, a specialist in obstetrics and gynecology, points out that smoking is the leading cause of infertility among couples, followed by alcohol consumption.

Separating Fact from Fiction

Numerous misconceptions surrounding bottled water's link to infertility persist. One common myth is that plastic materials used in bottles can disrupt hormonal balance and affect fertility. However, current scientific research fails to provide solid evidence to support this claim.

Most bottled water available on the market undergoes rigorous testing and adheres to stringent safety standards. The plastics used are generally designed to be safe and do not release significant amounts of harmful substances that could impact reproductive health. Nevertheless, further research is still necessary to fully comprehend the correlation. "There's no consistent research that proves the effects of bottled mineral water on infertility," stated Hasto Wardoyo, head of the National Population and Family Planning Agency (BKKBN).

It's crucial to focus on scientifically proven factors that contribute to infertility and seek guidance from healthcare professionals for accurate information and personalized advice.